Reinvention is never easy. Legacy brands that built their reputations over decades often find themselves caught between the pull of loyal customers and the push to attract a new generation. The challenge is not just knowing what to change but also how quickly to move. Two high-profile examples—J.C. Penney under Ron Johnson and Cracker Barrel under Julie Felss Masino—offer cautionary lessons for executives across retail and foodservice.
The J.C. Penney Lesson
When Ron Johnson took over J.C. Penney in 2011, he carried the halo of Apple’s retail success. Johnson immediately abolished coupons and discounts in favor of “everyday low pricing,” redesigned stores into boutique concepts, and attempted to reposition Penney’s as a hip destination. The problem? He moved too fast and ignored the company’s core shopper. J.C. Penney’s longtime customers had been conditioned to hunt for deals. Stripping away coupons felt like stripping away value. Sales plunged by nearly 25% in a year, the stock tanked, and Johnson was forced out after just 17 months.
The moral: reinvention without respecting consumer expectations is dangerous—even if the strategy looks sound on paper.
Cracker Barrel’s Balancing Act
Fast forward to today. Cracker Barrel, a nearly 56-year-old family-dining chain, has embarked on a modernization push under Masino, formerly of Taco Bell and Starbucks. The plan includes menu innovation, remodels, and a new logo. While the strategy was beginning to show results—four straight quarters of same-store sales growth—the logo change sparked a political and cultural backlash. Loyalists accused Cracker Barrel of abandoning its “country” roots, while social media amplified the controversy, shaving millions from its market value almost overnight.
The parallel with Penney’s isn’t exact, but the risk is similar: when a brand tinkers too visibly with its identity, customers may feel it no longer represents them. Just as Penney’s shoppers missed their coupons, Cracker Barrel’s fans may miss the nostalgic iconography—even if they weren’t visiting as often as before.
Why Masino May Avoid the Ron Johnson Trap
It’s important to note, however, that not every bold refresh ends in disaster. Johnson’s failure was rooted in ignoring customer behavior—he eliminated coupons entirely, despite data showing they were central to Penney’s value proposition. Masino’s approach has been more measured.
- Incremental vs. radical change. Johnson tried to flip Penney’s overnight. Masino is phasing in changes, testing remodels, and layering menu upgrades alongside branding shifts.
- Performance track record. Cracker Barrel had already logged consecutive quarters of growth before the backlash—traction Penney’s never achieved.
- Precedents of success. Domino’s rebuilt its reputation by revamping its pizza and marketing; Wendy’s modernized its logo without losing its voice; Taco Bell (where Masino previously led) captured new audiences with menu innovation while retaining its quirky appeal.
Cautions for Foodservice Brands
The lesson for food manufacturers and operators is clear: reinvention is necessary, but it must be paced, sequenced, and explained carefully. Respect legacy customers, test before rolling out, and communicate the “why” behind each change.
Cracker Barrel may yet prove that a legacy brand can modernize without alienating its soul. But the cautionary tale of Ron Johnson at J.C. Penney looms large: reinvention without empathy can undo decades of goodwill.
To learn more about FSIP’s Management Consulting Practice, click here.
Like the content? Sign up to receive our communications.
Recent Comments