The convenience store foodservice landscape is evolving rapidly, with c-stores competing against QSRs, fast-casual chains, and even grocery stores for share of stomach. To stand out, c-stores must go beyond just offering food—they need to create a compelling value proposition that resonates with busy consumers. By emphasizing convenience, quality, and cost-effectiveness, c-stores can solidify their place as a go-to destination for on-the-go dining. This requires strategic pricing, effective marketing, and a clear understanding of consumer preferences.
Understanding Consumer Perception of Value
Consumers assess value based on three primary factors: convenience, quality, and cost. A strong value proposition goes beyond price alone; it must include additional benefits that align with consumer preferences. Premium yet affordable options—such as Rutter’s made-to-order subs—enhance fair price perception while also driving impulse purchases, increasing basket size, and encouraging repeat visits.
A tiered pricing strategy, similar to those implemented by QSRs like McDonald’s, allows convenience stores to cater to a broad range of customers. Offering value at multiple levels gives consumers the flexibility to trade up or down based on their individual priorities, whether that be portion size, dietary considerations, or overall experience. Additionally, c-stores possess unique attributes that set them apart from QSRs, such as one-stop shopping convenience, grab-and-go efficiency, and loyalty programs that reinforce customer engagement.
Effective Marketing Strategies for Value Proposition
Marketing value effectively requires shifting consumer focus from cost to the benefits of time savings and convenience. Messaging that emphasizes “skip the wait” service or “grab-and-go without compromise” resonates with busy customers looking for quick, high-quality food options. Locally owned chains like Plaid Pantry leverage personalized rewards to drive loyalty, while brands like Chipotle highlight fresh, transparent ingredient sourcing—an approach c-stores can adopt to reinforce quality and trust.
To stand out, convenience stores should highlight the attributes where they excel, such as fast service, quality food offerings, and innovative loyalty programs. Clear, authentic communication around these strengths will help shape positive consumer perceptions and drive engagement.
Competing Against QSRs and Fast-Casual Outlets
As competitive lines blur between food-forward convenience stores, QSRs, and fast-casual restaurants, c-stores must differentiate their offerings. Immediate gratification remains a key advantage—no long drive-thru lines, no tipping expectations.
Bundling promotions that increase perceived value, such as Maverik’s “fuel and food” savings, create additional incentives for customers to make larger purchases. Moreover, many c-stores are developing signature menu items that establish them as food destinations in their own right. Limited-time offers (LTOs) and unique, crave-worthy menu innovations help generate excitement and encourage impulse buys.
Competing with Home-Cooked Meals
Economic pressures often push consumers toward cooking at home, making it essential for c-stores to frame their offerings as a smart alternative. Instead of positioning meals as “cheaper than home cooking,” emphasizing convenience and affordability compared to restaurant delivery is more effective.
Past economic downturns have shown that budget-friendly meal bundles and high-value promotions can maintain traffic. C-stores should highlight the true costs of home cooking, including ingredient expenses and preparation time, to reinforce the convenience and affordability of their ready-to-eat meals.
Differentiating Through Limited-Time Offers and Innovation
Consumer preferences may shift, but staple menu items remain consistent over time. To differentiate themselves, c-stores should use seasonal LTOs that introduce fresh, innovative flavors without disrupting core menus. Brands like Royal Farms leverage specialty chicken tenders for limited-run promotions, increasing perceived exclusivity and driving impulse purchases.
Consumers tend to gravitate toward comfort foods in uncertain times, making it beneficial for c-stores to offer nostalgic, familiar options while incorporating subtle innovations. Fast-casual restaurants like Panera regularly refresh their core menu with seasonal twists—c-stores should adopt a similar approach.
Navigating Pricing Challenges Amid Market Uncertainty
With ongoing supply chain disruptions and fluctuating ingredient costs, c-stores must adopt flexible strategies to maintain their value proposition. Securing supplier agreements and diversifying sourcing can help stabilize pricing. Smart retailers, like Yesway, hedge against volatility by adjusting portion sizes while keeping key price points intact.
Lessons from past economic challenges underscore the importance of agility. Whether through supplier shifts or adjusted pricing structures, maintaining consistency in quality and affordability is key to preserving consumer trust.
Final Thoughts
As c-store foodservice continues to evolve, the focus should be on value beyond just price. Offering a range of price points, emphasizing convenience and quality, and creating differentiation through innovation and promotions will enable c-stores to thrive in an increasingly competitive market. By strategically positioning their food offerings and effectively communicating their advantages, c-stores can strengthen their role as a go-to dining destination for on-the-go consumers.
Tim Powell is a Principal with Foodservice IP, a professional services firm aimed at delivering ideas for managers to guide informed business decisions. Foodservice IP will be delivering its 2025 C-Store Foodservice study in May 2025. See more details here.
To learn more about FSIP’s Management Consulting Practice, click here.
Like the content? Sign up to receive our communications.
Recent Comments